Premium Reduction CenterDUNCAN FINANCIAL GROUP · KEYSTONE

The premium audit

The audit came back and you owe more than you planned for.

An audit bill can be right. It can also carry mistakes that nobody on your side was assigned to check, and once it's paid, getting money back is much harder.

Start a conversationThe Employer Success Program

Here is one line off an audit worksheet.

A payroll audit line with office wages left in a carpentry class code 412,000 dollars of payroll is reported under class 5403 Carpentry at a rate of 14.80 per hundred. 96,000 dollars of that is office payroll that belongs in class 8810 Clerical at 0.28 per hundred. Rated correctly that 96,000 costs 269 dollars instead of 14,208, a difference of 13,939 dollars. CODEDESCRIPTIONPAYROLLRATEPREMIUM 5403Carpentry$412,00014.80$60,976 $96,000 of that is office payroll. Three people who never leave the building. Rated as 5403 Carpentry14.80$14,208 Rated as 8810 Clerical0.28$269 Overcharged on one line $13,939 One line on one audit. Most bills have several codes, and the payroll split is the auditor's judgment, not a fact. Nobody checks it unless you do.
Illustration, with real class codes and representative rates. Rates vary by insurer, state and year. The point is the shape of the error, not these numbers.

Where audits usually go wrong

  • Payroll placed in a class code that doesn't match the work the person actually does.
  • Pay that shouldn't be counted, counted anyway.
  • Subcontractors charged even though they carried their own coverage, because the certificates weren't on file.
  • Officer or owner payroll above the state's limit.
  • Estimated payroll at the start of the year that never matched how the business actually grew.

None of that is anyone being careless on purpose. It's that the auditor works from what's in front of them, and most companies don't prepare for the audit at all.

Which one are you?

You have a bill in front of you now. If it surprised you, check the due date, then send me the audit worksheet and what you expected to pay. Recovering money after a bill is paid is harder than questioning it before.

Request an audit review

Your next audit is still ahead of you. AuditCheck walks through what to have ready, the mistakes to look for, and the worksheets to use. It is free.

Get AuditCheck

Watch: problems with the payroll audit

Problems with the workers' comp premium payroll audit

Where the Employer Success Program comes in

It starts with a Diagnostic and Plan. We read your loss runs, your mod worksheet and your key contracts, and we talk with the people who run the work. You get the pattern behind your claims and a short list of what's worth fixing first.

From there our claims, HR, safety and fleet people work alongside yours, and you get a Score Card at the start and every year after, measured against your own starting point.

How the program works

Start with a conversation

Tell me what the audit came back at and what you expected. I read these myself and reply within two business days.

Rather pick a time now? Book a 30-minute premium audit review. It's on Teams.