Premium Reduction CenterDUNCAN FINANCIAL GROUP · KEYSTONE

Premium up, few or no claims

Few or no claims last year, and you're paying more anyway.

Nobody got hurt, nobody backed into anything, nobody sued. And the renewal still went up.

Start a conversationThe Employer Success Program

Your claims record is only part of what the underwriter prices. The rest is in a file most owners have never seen.

Do you know what's in yours? Here is one line out of it.

Illustration of an insurance company history sheet Four policy years. The top two are written by Midstate Mutual Casualty, NAIC 14990. The bottom two are written by Midstate Security Insurance, NAIC 32859. The insurance company and NAIC columns change partway down the list while the policy stays with the same group. POLICYINSURANCE COMPANY NAICEFFECTIVE ••••••1247Midstate Mutual Casualty Co.1499004/01/2025 ••••••1247Midstate Mutual Casualty Co.1499004/01/2024 ••••••0982Midstate Security Insurance Co.3285904/01/2023 ••••••0982Midstate Security Insurance Co.3285904/01/2022 Same group.Different insurer. Illustration of an insurance company history sheet Four policy years. The top two are written by Midstate Mutual Casualty, NAIC 14990. The bottom two are written by Midstate Security Insurance, NAIC 32859. The insurance company and NAIC both change partway down the list. INSURANCE COMPANYNAIC Midstate Mutual Casualty Co.14990 Midstate Mutual Casualty Co.14990 Midstate Security Insurance Co.32859 Midstate Security Insurance Co.32859 Same group.Different insurer.
Illustration, not a client's sheet. The company name and the NAIC number both change partway down the list. The group name on the bill may not change at all.

Put last year's policy beside this year's. Did the underwriting company change?

If it did, that is worth asking about before your renewal. Most insurance groups hold several separate companies, and they do not have to charge the same rates for the same work. The name on your bill may not have changed at all.

Be clear about what that tells you, because it is narrower than it looks. It shows the underwriting company changed. It does not show why, it does not show whether your rate went up or down, and it says nothing about what is available to you now. Those are the things worth asking.

Bring the renewal that surprised you. We will work out what is worth checking.

Start a conversation

Every line is priced on its own

Workers' comp, auto, property, liability and umbrella each get their own price, and each insurance company has its own formulas for setting it. On workers' comp, the rating bureau sets your experience mod, and then the insurance company adjusts from there. On the other lines there's no bureau number. The company rates your history its own way.

Those formulas look at more than last year: your history over several years, how your industry is running, what the last inspection said, your drivers' records, what your buildings would cost to replace today, and what your contracts make you responsible for. Very little of that shows up on the renewal summary.

Why a good year doesn't show up yet

On workers' comp, the mod doesn't count last year yet. On auto and liability, one claim from a few years back can outweigh several clean years, because claims cost far more to settle than they used to.

When did someone last look at your company the way the underwriter does?

All of it, before the renewal. If the honest answer is “at renewal,” you saw the file after the price was already set.

A clean year is still the cheapest year to fix whatever is coming. The claims that will show up in your price two years from now are being set up now.

Where the Employer Success Program comes in

It starts with a Diagnostic and Plan. We read your loss runs, your mod worksheet and your key contracts, and we talk with the people who run the work. You get the pattern behind your claims and a short list of what's worth fixing first.

From there our claims, HR, safety and fleet people work alongside yours, and you get a Score Card at the start and every year after, measured against your own starting point.

How the program works

Start with a conversation

Tell me what went up and by how much, line by line if you have it. I read these myself and reply within two business days.

Rather pick a time now? Book a 30-minute renewal discussion. It's on Teams.